Head-to-Head Comparison

eVirtualAssistants vs Magic: Honest 2026 Comparison

Magic offers premium on-demand and dedicated VAs at $30-40/hr with 24/7 availability. eVirtualAssistants offers vetted dedicated VAs from $4/hr.

Browse candidates and submit standard jobs free within your allowance, subject to approval. Basic Hiring starts at $67/month; Serious Hiring is $147/month. VA compensation and optional recruiting services are separate. Compare current platform plans.

Magic is positioned as a premium on-demand executive assistant service with strong vetting and 24/7 availability. eVirtualAssistants is a dedicated VA marketplace with vetted offshore talent at a fraction of Magic's cost.

What is Magic?

Magic (getmagic.com) provides premium on-demand and dedicated virtual assistant services with rigorous vetting and AI-powered task routing, founded in 2015.

Key characteristics of Magic:

  • On-demand and dedicated tiers
  • $30-40/hr typical
  • 24/7 availability
  • AI-powered task routing
  • Premium vetting

Why eVirtualAssistants Wins for Most Buyers

If you need consistent recurring VA support (not on-demand bursts), eVA delivers similar quality at 85%+ savings.

1. Cost: $4/hr vs $30-40/hr

Massive savings for ongoing roles.

2. Better continuity

Dedicated VA learns your systems vs Magic's potential VA rotation.

3. Hourly flexibility

Agree VA compensation directly; platform access and optional services are separate.

4. Multi-region talent

Time-zone coverage Magic charges premium for.

Side-by-Side

FeatureMagiceVirtualAssistants
Starting price$30-40/hr
$4/hr
ModelOn-demand + dedicated
Dedicated VA
Availability24/7
Scheduled hours
ContinuityCan rotate
Same VA every time

eVirtualAssistants wins for ongoing dedicated work. Magic wins for premium on-demand executive support.

Get Vetted Dedicated VAs at 1/8 the Cost

From $4/hr - no premium pricing.

At-a-Glance Comparison

Don't bury the lead. Here's what matters.

FeatureeVirtualAssistantsMagic
Starting price
$4/hr
$30-40/hr
VA pool
PH, India, LATAM
Global, premium-vetted
Vetting
Multi-stage
Premium screening (top 1% claim)
Time-to-hire
Days
Days
Languages
English, Spanish (LATAM)
English
Availability
Scheduled hours
24/7
Replacement
Free
Yes
Contract
Hourly
Subscription tiers
Continuity
Dedicated VA
Can rotate (on-demand tier)
Specialties
Admin, CRM, design, dev, customer support
Executive admin, research, scheduling
The Short Answer

Which Platform Should You Choose?

eVirtualAssistants wins on cost and continuity. Magic wins on 24/7 on-demand premium executive support.

Choose eVirtualAssistants if:

  • You need ongoing recurring work done
  • You want lower cost
  • You value VA continuity
  • You don't need 24/7

Choose Magic if:

  • You need 24/7 on-demand executive support
  • Budget is not a constraint
  • You value Magic's AI-powered routing

Ready to skip the hiring headaches?

Pros & Cons (Neutral Comparison)

eVirtualAssistants

Pros
  • From $4/hr
  • Dedicated VA continuity
  • Hourly flexibility
  • Multi-region
Cons
  • Not 24/7 by default

Magic

Pros
  • 24/7 availability
  • AI-powered routing
  • Premium vetting
Cons
  • $30-40/hr - premium pricing
  • VA rotation in on-demand tier
  • Subscription tiers

Who Is Each Platform Best For?

eVirtualAssistants is best for:

  • Ongoing 20-40 hr/week dedicated roles
  • Cost-conscious operators
  • Multi-region time-zone needs

Magic is best for:

  • C-suite executives needing 24/7 burst support
  • On-demand high-stakes scheduling
  • Premium-budget buyers

When Magic Wins

If you're a C-suite executive needing 24/7 on-demand burst support - last-minute booking changes, late-night research requests, weekend scheduling fires - Magic's premium model is genuinely built for that. eVirtualAssistants is built for predictable recurring work, not on-demand emergencies.

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

Magic excels for premium 24/7 on-demand executive support. eVirtualAssistants excels for cost-effective dedicated recurring VA work.

eVirtualAssistants at $4/hr - one-eighth the cost.

Stop Interviewing. Start Automating.

Don't spend 20 hours screening resumes. Search our database for Verified, AI-Ready Virtual Assistants who are ready to work today.

Get our new guides in Google

Make eVirtualAssistants a preferred source and our hiring guides, rate data, and platform comparisons show up higher in your Google results.

Opens Google's source preferences without leaving this page.